Did Time Begin?

Since the William Lane Craig article was published, I have got into some fun arguments about the concept of time.  If time and space were created by God, as creationists believe, there is a difficulty facing their position.  The difficulty with it led me to abandon it when I became an atheist.  My goal is not to silence creationists or disrespect them but they simply must admit the problem of time in respects to God.  It isn’t trivial. 

If there was a time God created the universe, then that means the universe had a beginning.  The universe is then, not eternal.  But there was a “time” when God existed and the universe did not.  The universe has a beginning, remember.  God does not have a beginning.  The problem should be obvious. 

God existed “before” the universe began.  He initiated it, ergo, God acted as a cause which brought about the universe as an effect.  The idea that a cause precedes an effect calls us to remember that if God acted with intent to bring about a future result–he had a concept of the future and participated in a preparatory action.  The action of thinking the universe into being occurred prior to its fulfillment.  Or was it simultaneous?  These questions would be meaningless to us without a concept of time.  But suppose we confirm God did create the universe as an effect to his cause.  In this scenario, God is behaving in a chronological and sequential way.  There was no universe…then there is.  Time could not have begun in the most literal sense, with the creation of the universe.  I don’t think atheism’s many attempts to explain this are more convincing than the creationists but once again, we see a thrilling challenge to our intellect and work hard to uncover some pieces of the puzzle.  We attempt to arrive at a philosophically satisfying explanation that is scientifically feasible.  Phrases like, “and then God created the universe” are meaningless without our sense of time.  If time goes back infinitely, we would never arrive at a single moment in time because the starting point from which proceeded towards the present is moving backwards in time rapidly as is the infinite past.  Infinite regresses are impossible.  The Creationists like William Lane Craig AND the atheists like Richard Dawkins admitthat the universe must have had a beginning because we have arrived at a moment…but wouln’t it follow that God could not have an eternal past?  How could he have arrived at the incident/moment/process of creating the universe?  To posit God as a being with a personality, will and desires yet outside the constraints of time and space beg the question of how such a being can create things IN time and IN space…the limited domain of time and space would be extraordinary because God Himself would have made a domain in which things happen after other things…but wait–but when he did it he must have realized how familiar it felt.  Thus, time is a pain in the ass for the Creationist and a non-threatening mystery of life for the agnostic or atheist naturalist.


2 thoughts on “Did Time Begin?

  1. twentyone12joeyd@yahoo.com says:

    Maybe we are playing semantics here a little bit. We live in time and perceive our world through it. Therefore we really have no better way to say “god created the universe or time BEFORE there was time” Obviously the statement is slightly self-defeating, but how else are you going to put it? Its not something (existing apart from time) that any human has ever experienced, which creates a problem for anyone trying to express something about it.

  2. timmyshort says:

    We are playing semantics…but we also presuming that there is such a thing as “outside of time…” this would be beyond the grasp of mortals but when Christians trash the Big Bang, couldn’t evolutionists say that it too is beyond our grasp? Christians ask rational questions about what caused the Big Bang and demand answers. When the logic runs dry on the argument of God pre-existing the Universe…well, who the fuck is to say what God can and cannot do…the same argument to justify his atrocious behavior in ancient times or any other hard question.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: